5 Games I Finished Multiple Times

I’m a grown up.  That means I don’t have nearly as much gaming time as I used to.  That means most games tend to get the “one-and-done” treatment.  That means that I tend not to complete many games multiple times.  That means…I don’t think I can carry on doing this “That means…” thing.  I know.  You’re upset.  It was pretty hilarious whilst it lasted.  But you’ll just have to move on.  Much like I’m going to right now.

Rambling aside, I tend not to finish games repeatedly, simply because I don’t have the time to before I move onto the next experience.  But there are a few games I’ve played during my more recent adult life that have had the special privilege of not being returned to the shelf once I’ve finished it.  This is dedicated to those games!

Some rules here.  Games that require multiple playthroughs don’t count (sorry Nier: Automata).  Super short games don’t count either, so things like Blue Estate are going to be ignored.  They need to be games I’ve played since being a proper grown up and having a real job, so don’t expect anything before the past couple of generations.  On with the show!

Mass Effect

Mass Effect

Seven times.  I played this from start to finish seven times.  It was absolute madness to spend that length of time on a single game, but utterly worth it.  There were so many different ways to play it, with multiple classes as well as multiple ways to approach a situation and alter the story.

Mass Effect
Nothing to do with playing the game multiple times, but this really made me laugh.

My final playthrough was on Insane mode.  God knows why I did that, but it really was a slog as the enemies just became bullet sponges.  Still!  There was a lot to love in this universe, so much so that I went back to see those things seven times…

Oh, and I ended up taking my original playthrough through to the future games, making those other playthroughs moot.

Dark Souls

Dark Souls

This was an odd one for me, as I finished the game and then started playing it through again immediately so I could get the other ending.  Not that I had a clue what either ending meant.  Honestly I think it was just an excuse for me to go back and experience it all again.

Dark Souls
That’s a whole lot of demon butt.

Having finished the game, I found out that there were other bosses and such that I didn’t even know existed, let alone had found.  So back in I went, armed with my new knowledge.  I got thoroughly killed by most of them (along with the minions in the areas.  Screw those wheel skeletons) but going back through the worlds was just as much fun the second time around as the first.

Alan Wake


Alan Wake did something that I don’t like in games.  It hid content behind difficulty modes.  If you wanted to see everything in the game you had to play it on the hardest setting.  Thankfully, normal mode was actually fairly tame, meaning that I felt alright about going into Nightmare mode.  For a hardest setting, it wasn’t all that tough (HASHTAG MLGPRO!).  Anyway, I’d enjoyed the main game a lot.  I found the story interesting, the atmosphere spot on, and the soundtrack fantastic.  The gameplay wasn’t half bad either.

The light + gunfire gameplay still works as far as I’m concerned.  Using flares and other light sources as offense and defence works very well.

I’m pretty sure there isn’t anything in this game that I didn’t do.  All the collectibles, all the DLC, all the extra challenges, everything.  I know it has its flaws, but I found it utterly compelling, and I’m one of those that still hopes for a proper follow-up one day.  I’m not holding my breath though.

DmC: Devil May Cry

DmC: Devil May Cry (2013)

No, you shut up!  Whilst I found the new Dante a bit irritating (plus that who “Not in a million years.” thing felt like a deliberate swipe at fans of the previous games), I considered the world and gameplay to be absolutely spot on.  The real world/demon world thing lead to some really intersting environmental designs and trversal challenges, and whilst the combat was a little easier than previous installments, it was still incredibly satisfying.

DmC Devil May Cry
He’s certainly not one of the hardest bosses I’ve ever faced, but the it does so much so well!

Add to that the bosses, that were incredibly varied and fun to fight.  The Bob Barbas one above was insane in its presentation alone.  I didn’t play this a second time until years later, but it was just as fun the second time around.  It held up pretty well in spite of this being a pretty hated entry in the series.


XCOM 2 Logo

Well obviously.  Did anyone expect this to not be here?  Literally hundreds of hours across numerous playthroughs that are different every time depending on successes and failures as well as the choices you make in the “overworld”.  This is my go to game any time I need a play through of something comfortable.  Comfort gaming if you like.

The War of the Chosen expansion adds such a huge amount to XCOM 2.  It practically makes it a whole new game.

If you missed it, I recently did a week by week run through of my most recent campaign featuring friends and family.  Needless to say, not eveyone made it thought…

Some honourable mentions.  Alpha Protocol was a horribly under appreciated spy thriller with tons of choice about how to play that had genuine consequences.  I needed a few playthroughs to see everything I wanted to.  DOOM (2016) got a couple of run throughs by virtue of being brilliant and having a fun enough core gameplay loop for me to want to do it all again.  Fallout 3, because I really wanted to blow up Megaton…

How about you?  What have you played over and over again?  Are they comfort games or ones that genuinely needed more playthroughs just because they were that much fun?  Tell me about them so I can absolutely not play them because I don’t have time to!

51 thoughts on “5 Games I Finished Multiple Times

  1. I ended up playing through Fire Emblem: Fates three times, though that was mostly because it had three different paths. To be honest, outside of a few classic games such as Super Mario Bros. 3, I don’t tend to replay games a whole lot. I do revisit some of my favorites on occasion, but there’s usually a bit of time between playthroughs – especially if they’re heavy on story.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. There were 3 versions of Fates, is that right?

      It’s a rarity to replay games as you get older due to there being less free time, but there are always those I’d like to play through again. Even with the best intentions it tends not to happen though.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Yes. They were: Birthright, Conquest, and Revelation. They’re all entirely different campaigns, so there was more of an incentive to replay it one time right after the other.

        I know what you mean; at the end of the day, new games tend to take priority over ones I’ve already played not only because it’s more productive, but also so I can get more material for my site.

        Liked by 1 person

  2. I’m nearly done with my 3rd Mass Effect playthrough myself. Gone with female Shepard this time and I have to say I don’t miss male Shepard all that much. I love the world building in this game, it still blows me away.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Off the top of my head, I’ve played through Final Fantasy, Super Mario Bros., Dark Forces, the Batman Arkham games more than a few times. I’m 100% sure I’ve done others as well though.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Resident Evil 2 will be the game i’ve completed most that isnt a 10 minute speed run. As I’ve probably beaten Super Mario Bros 100 times.

    Final Fantasy VII is probably the game I’ve spent most time playing and probably completed that 20 times.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Great post! And yeah, I’ve done Mass Effect a few times (although not 7!). Such a great game. Otherwise the only ones I can really think of that I’ve played over and over since I also reached ‘gaming adulthood’ are the Uncharted games.

    Liked by 1 person

  6. Really enjoyed this post! I’m glad you’ve found a few games that you’re able to take the time and enjoy multiple times while adulting!

    Being a grown up myself, I tend to play games that don’t have a defined ending, such as the Pokemon series or Harvest Moon franchise, games I can pick up and just keep going to help relax. There are quite a few games that I have finished multiple times, with Super Mario RPG: Legend of the Seven Stars being my favorite. Paper Mario and Ocarina of Time are another couple of favorites.

    Liked by 2 people

  7. Man I wish we got another Alan Wake! I have replayed many a game in my day but usually shorter stuff. Even when I love a long game, it is rare I go back for another play through. Super Mario Bros. 3, Jak and Daxter, Uncharted, Prince of Persia: The Sands of Time, and Mirror’s Edge are probably among my most replayed (though the latter more in time trial form than full play throughs).

    Liked by 1 person

  8. What a great idea for a list! Very interesting about DMC! I love the series but haven’t played the reboot , I just can’t get over new Dante 😐…perhaps it’s time for me to bite the bullet!

    I haven’t replayed many games, my top one is resi 4. It’s like an old friend, I always stick it on if I’m a bit fed up (or, when as frequently happens, I can’t afford a new game!) Hasn’t had a 2018 play through yet though so that might be happening soon!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I like the idea of an annual playthrough game. I’ll see if I can pick one out that I’d like to do each year some time.

      DmC was a good reboot. The gameplay was spot on, the soundtrack was fantastic. Everything felt great. But because Dante is such a loved character, the retconned changes and the deliberate digs at the original fans really rubbed people the wrong way. If you want a top notch hack & slash game, it’s well worth playing the definitive edition of it.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. I’ll agree with the story being a touch weak (although I like how it was presented) and the characters being irritating. It’s the hate for the gameplay that I disagree with. Everything feels fantastically fluid when the fighting starts.


  9. Most of my repeats are Final Fantasy (I know, shock, right?). I’ve played FFVI, FFVIII, and FFIX multiple times, and I’ve given FFVII two or three tries to complete. I didn’t for lack of interest, but rather life circumstances. I’ve seen the end multiple times, and have probably read enough about it to fill a library. Mario games were also my go-to, because they’re simple, fun, and not to difficult. I can’t think of a modern game that I’ve played on repeat, since I have so little time for gaming. I tend to do one and done at this point after I’ve beaten something.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s